Review your data settings

Cookies are set through this site to recognise your repeat visits and preferences, serve more relevant ads, facilitate social sharing, and to analyse traffic. By using the site, you consent to the use of cookies that may process personal data for these purposes in line with our privacy statement and cookie policy.

Menu

Ruth Dudley Edwards: Kilclooney's tweeting can be tasteless, but McElduff has plumbed the depths

If you look for attention on social media, you best be careful what you wish for, writes Ruth Dudley Edwards

24
Barry McElduff

I was just poised to write about 'Tweeting Lord Kilclooney' (as I think of him these days), though he was just humble UUP MP John Taylor when I met him in the 1980s. Then the furore about Sinn Fein MP Barry McElduff's Kingsmill-related tweet burst upon the airwaves.

So I decided to look as well at another parliamentarian who is achieving social media notoriety.

First, their Twitter profiles.

The 80-year-old @KilclooneyJohn is factual: "Former Cabinet Minister in NI Government; former MEP; and former MP at Westminster."

Fifty-one-year-old @BarryMcElduff is more political: "Sinn Fein MP for West Tyrone. Offices in Omagh & Strabane. Tá Gaeilge agam. Published Author. GAA member. Demanding full speaking rights in Dail."

Taylor survived five Official IRA bullets in the head in 1972, although he had to endure extensive reconstructive surgery on his jaw.

"He was a person who was entitled to respect," said David Trimble, who met him in 1973.

"After coming within an inch of losing his life, he was still involved and not in any way intimidated."

Video: Barry McElduff's Kingsmill bread 'joke' video

He became a very successful businessman and politician, but I went back to Dean Godson's magisterial Trimble biography to check out my impression that one of his lordship's distinguishing characteristic has always been a love of making mischief.

Describing a key moment of tortuous negotiations in 1999 when no one knew which way the UUP deputy leader would jump, Mr Godson commented: "It was the latest instalment of the cat and mouse game which Taylor played with both the British Government and his own party and left the cognoscenti guessing for days."

Among the motives Mr Godson considered was that he simply enjoyed "winding people up" and revelled in the attention."

As his tweets show, that's still important to him, though - as always - a wily politician takes advantage of the publicity.

He's been at this for only six months, but he certainly gets quite a few nationalists going.

In August, in response to the controversy about an Irish Language Act, he tweeted: "Everyone, Nationalist and Unionist, must have equal opportunity. Politically Unionists are the majority and so the two are not equals."

24
Families of murdered workmen attend an evening service in 1976 as six coffins of IRA victims are brought to church in Bessbrook the night before the funerals of those killed in the Provisional IRA's infamous sectarian Whitecross (Kingsmill) Massacre. The IRA lined up the occupants of a workers minibus carrying 11 protestants and one catholic, before releasing the catholic man and mowing down the 10 protestant workmen, leaving the critically injured Mr Alan Black for dead. Alan Lewis Photopress

The ensuing row (Mairtin O Muilleoir claimed he meant "we (nationalists) will have to stay at the back of the bus") gave his lordship the chance to tell the Press that his point was that since nationalists were "a political minority", they couldn't "dictate terms".

Then in November was: "Simon Coveney is stirring things up. Very dangerous non statesman like role! Clearly hoping to undermine the Indian."

He claimed, rather unconvincingly, after an outcry that a) he couldn't spell Taoiseach Varadkar's name, and b) the term was shorthand, but despite a complaint to the House of Lords Standards Commissioner, allegations of racism don't really stick, and not just because Lord Kilclooney has a long record of support for pre-Erdogan Turkey.

But it did help sow doubts about Coveney's motives for going green.

He caused another uproar with a tweet describing Moeen Ali as a "non-English" member of the England cricket team - causing Piers Morgan furiously to denounce to his millions of followers this "old racist dinosaur".

This gave Kilclooney the chance to bang on about differences between country and nation and race and nationality, which I might argue another day.

There are no such ambiguities with Mr McElduff, whose career as a republican activist I've followed since he became locally famous for venomous street agitation against the RUC in the 1990s.

There are no such ambiguities with Mr McElduff, whose career as a republican activist I've followed since he became locally famous for venomous street agitation against the RUC in the 1990s.

His enjoyment of amateur dramatics these days inspires "humorous" videos starring himself.

His most recent went spectacularly wrong.

I've considered the possibility that posting a photo of himself balancing a Kingsmill loaf on his head just after midnight on the anniversary of the massacre might have been because - as he claimed later - he "had not realised or imagined for a second any possible link between product brand name and Kingsmill Anniversary".

Unfortunately, it makes no sense.

Mr McElduff has built his political reputation as a banger of the tribal drum and he puts to good use his knowledge of what winds up the Prods and delights republican rank-and-file.

Lord Kilclooney can be tasteless: Barry McElduff has simply been disgusting.

1 / 24
Barry McElduff
2 / 24
Lord Kilclooney
3 / 24
Families of murdered workmen attend an evening service in 1976 as six coffins of IRA victims are brought to church in Bessbrook the night before the funerals of those killed in the Provisional IRA's infamous sectarian Whitecross (Kingsmill) Massacre. The IRA lined up the occupants of a workers minibus carrying 11 protestants and one catholic, before releasing the catholic man and mowing down the 10 protestant workmen, leaving the critically injured Mr Alan Black for dead. Alan Lewis Photopress
4 / 24
The victims of the Kingsmill massacre (clockwise from top left): Robert Chambers; John Bryans; Joseph Lemmon; James McWhirter; Robert Freeburn; Robert Walker; Reginald Chapman; Kenneth Worton; John McConville and Walter Chapman
5 / 24
Kimgsmill massacre aftermath
6 / 24
Walter Chapman
7 / 24
John McConville
8 / 24
Kenneth Worton
9 / 24
Reginald Chapman
10 / 24
Robert Walker
11 / 24
Robert Freeburn
12 / 24
James McWhirter
13 / 24
Joseph Lemmon
14 / 24
John Bryans
15 / 24
Robert Chambers
16 / 24
The funeral service for five victims of the Kingsmills massacre at the Presbyterian church grounds in Bessbrook
17 / 24
Alan Black was shot 18 times but survived the Kingsmills massacre
18 / 24
Alan Black in hospital after the IRA shot him and killed 10 of his colleagues at Kingsmills
19 / 24
Alan Black:Survivor of the Kingsmill, Armagh, Massacre/Shooting, when he was shot with his 10 workmates in an ambushon their way home from work by gunmen. Pictured at the Kingsmill Memorial monument. 4/1/1981
20 / 24
A man lays a wreath at the Kingsmill memorial in South Armagh (PA)
21 / 24
People attend a roadside service marking the 42nd anniversary of the Kingsmill massacre (Brian Lawless/PA)
22 / 24
Karen Armstrong holds a photograph of her brother John McConville, who was killed in the Kingsmill attack
23 / 24
Sisters Cathy Michale, Colleen McKenna and Eileen Reavey unveil the monument to commemorate their brothers in Whitecross, Armagh
24 / 24
The crowd assembled at the service of remembrance for the victims held at the Town Hall in Bessbrook yesterday to mark the 40th anniversary of the atrocity